American National (ANICO) Insurance Review & Complaints: Life, Health & Disability Insurance (2023)

American National has a major focus on financial products including life insurance, health, disability, annuities, and more. The company also writes personal property & casualty insurance including car insurance and home insurance. There are also commercial insurance products available. With a variety of insurance options available and a longstanding history, they can support many of your insurance needs and provide excellent service and respect to clients.

Learn more by reading our American National (ANICO) Insurance review below.

American National is a group of companies writing insurance products in all 50 states and the District of Columbia, although the type of policy and variety of options available varies by state. New York is the one state where only affiliated companies and subsidiaries are licensed to do business.

American National products are mainly sold through a team of insurance agents, although some life insurance products are available for purchase online. Agents can be found through the website for all states and some U.S. territories where the company is licensed.

Keeping reading for more information on ANICO insurance reviews and use our helpful tool to compare insurance rates with American National (ANICO) Insurance rates. Comparing rates is generally to your benefit, and the process usually steers you towards a better rate and a decent company within the wide range of companies available. 

What types of insurance does American National offer?

American National does not provide detailed product descriptions online; rather, they point customers to agents for more information regarding policies. The types of products that are available include both personal and commercial lines of insurance, and they also administer pension plans for small businesses.

American National Life Insurance

American National writes a variety of life insurance products including whole, term, and universal life insurance. The company also offers annuities, both fixed and variable. A life insurance policy is the only product that is sold directly and not solely through agents via a separate website. Information on American National annuities and more can be found below.

American National Personal Lines Property & Casualty Insurance

The property & casualty products from American National cover the basics of personal insurance, including:

• Auto Insurance
• Home Insurance
• Recreational Vehicle insurance (such as watercraft, RVs, collector cars)
• Renters Insurance

The website does state that the company offers a cash back incentive for loyal customers. If the client has their home and auto insured through American National and is claim free for a period of three years, they are issued 25 percent of their eligible home and auto premiums back in cash (not available in all states). Customers who have commented on their insurance programs seem to be pleased with it. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) provides customer ratings. Use this site to find insurance information for your state.

American National also runs the subsidiary ANPAC. What does ANPAC stand for? It stands for American National Property and Casualty Company. ANPAC is run out of Missouri and offers life insurance options and more.

American National Credit Insurance

These product offerings are designed to make payments on debts in the event that the policyholder becomes unable to do so. Policy types include credit life, credit disability, credit involuntary unemployment, and property policies.

American National Commercial Insurance

Commercial insurance policies are available for small businesses. American National also offers agribusiness coverage options.

American National Health Insurance

Plans from American National include major medical, Medicare supplemental, and disability insurance.

Are American National’s rates competitive?

Online quoting is not available for most of the products from American National. Only its term life insurance and whole life insurance options can be bought online, through the American National Direct website. Online quoting requires providing contact information that allows the company to contact you by phone in order to follow up on the quote and complete the application which may put off some insurance shoppers who simply want to get numbers without being contacted.

American National is very focused on its life insurance products and likely has competitive rates. For other products, it’s difficult to say what sort of rates this company might offer. As an agent-driven company, it’s unlikely that its auto rates will be as competitive as major direct-buy insurance companies. For comparison, check out the chart below, which features different rates from several top companies.

Average Monthly Car Insurance Rates Comparison for Top 10 Companies by State

State	Allstate Average Monthly Rates	American Family Average Monthly Rates	Farmers Average Monthly Rates	Geico Average Monthly Rates	Liberty Mutual Average Monthly Rates	Nationwide Average Monthly Rates	Progressive Average Monthly Rates	State Farm Average Monthly Rates	Travelers Average Monthly Rates
Alaska	262.11	346.09	-	240.00	441.30	-	255.24	185.68	-
Alabama	275.96	-	348.82	238.88	333.79	221.89	370.88	399.85	308.15
Arkansas	429.17	-	354.82	290.39	-	321.82	442.67	232.42	497.78
Arizona	408.68	-	416.67	188.73	-	291.34	298.13	396.35	257.06
California	377.75	-	416.57	240.47	252.87	387.77	237.47	350.19	279.13
Colorado	461.43	311.09	440.85	257.64	233.15	311.62	352.66	272.56	-
Connecticut	485.97	-	-	256.14	606.91	306.03	410.03	248.02	500.36
District of Columbia	539.08	-	-	307.73	-	404.08	414.19	339.50	-
Delaware	526.34	-	-	310.61	1530.00	360.85	348.49	372.24	348.53
Florida	620.04	-	-	315.30	447.35	361.63	465.28	283.14	-
Georgia	350.89	-	-	248.10	837.79	540.41	374.94	282.07	-
Hawaii	181.12	-	396.99	279.91	265.80	212.65	181.49	86.69	-
Iowa	247.16	251.82	202.98	191.35	367.94	227.95	199.63	185.38	452.45
Idaho	340.73	310.73	264.02	230.89	191.79	252.68	-	155.66	268.86
Illinois	433.70	317.94	383.77	231.60	189.80	225.98	294.72	195.41	208.31
Indiana	331.57	306.64	286.46	188.42	481.78	-	324.83	200.75	282.81
Kansas	334.19	178.87	308.65	268.39	398.70	206.30	345.37	226.67	361.79
Kentucky	595.33	-	-	386.13	494.25	458.60	462.30	279.53	545.97
Louisiana	499.90	-	-	512.88	-	-	622.59	381.59	-
Maine	306.30	-	230.85	235.25	360.95	-	303.63	183.22	187.75
Maryland	436.10	-	-	319.39	774.80	242.97	341.24	330.07	-
Massachusetts	225.71	-	-	125.85	361.61	-	319.59	113.49	294.83
Michigan	1908.55	-	708.63	535.84	1666.67	527.28	447.05	1047.13	731.16
Minnesota	377.67	293.44	261.45	291.55	1130.30	243.87	-	172.25	-
Missouri	341.35	273.91	359.35	240.44	376.56	188.78	284.93	224.41	-
Mississippi	411.84	-	-	340.60	371.33	229.71	359.07	248.37	310.78
Montana	389.34	-	325.63	300.20	110.51	289.86	360.90	201.48	-
North Carolina	599.20	-	-	244.72	181.89	237.34	198.55	256.55	261.06
North Dakota	389.11	317.70	257.71	222.35	1071.07	213.36	301.92	213.38	-
Nebraska	266.57	184.59	333.11	319.79	520.13	217.00	313.17	203.23	-
New Hampshire	227.08	-	-	134.59	703.70	207.59	224.54	182.12	-
New Jersey	476.13	-	634.75	229.58	563.89	-	331.06	627.26	354.54
New Mexico	350.05	-	359.63	371.53	-	292.87	259.93	195.06	-
Nevada	447.64	453.43	466.30	305.17	516.80	289.76	338.55	483.03	446.70
New York	395.08	-	-	202.35	545.06	334.41	314.26	373.72	381.57
Ohio	266.44	126.26	285.25	155.60	369.15	275.07	286.41	208.99	261.26
Oklahoma	309.89	-	345.20	286.45	572.89	-	402.70	234.73	-
Oregon	397.16	293.94	312.79	268.34	361.21	264.74	302.43	227.62	241.02
Pennsylvania	332.01	-	-	217.10	504.60	233.36	370.92	228.69	653.54
Rhode Island	413.29	-	-	466.89	515.34	367.47	435.92	200.54	575.79
South Carolina	325.29	-	390.99	264.83	-	302.12	381.09	255.95	-
South Dakota	393.64	337.29	314.07	245.02	626.33	228.14	312.73	192.19	-
Tennessee	402.40	-	285.84	273.62	517.22	285.41	304.74	219.94	228.21
Texas	457.12	404.06	-	271.94	-	322.30	388.72	240.00	-
Utah	297.20	308.23	325.67	247.13	360.65	248.88	319.18	387.15	-
Virginia	282.23	-	-	171.79	-	172.75	208.22	189.08	-
Vermont	265.87	-	-	182.98	301.76	177.35	434.76	365.24	-
Washington	295.04	309.42	246.83	214.05	332.89	177.49	267.46	208.32	-
West Virginia	318.39	-	-	176.73	243.70	-	-	177.19	-
Wisconsin	404.53	126.11	314.79	327.18	563.24	435.42	260.74	198.96	-
Wyoming	364.49	-	255.78	291.38	165.78	265.60	366.76	191.96	-

As you can see, rates can differ greatly based on where you live and the auto insurance company you go with.

How do I file an American National claim?

How do you file American National insurance claims? American National provides very little information on its website with regard to claims. The website does have claims forms available to download for some of the company’s products, including life and health insurance.

However, with regard to property & casualty claims, the client is directed to contact a toll-free number. This is likely a function of American National’s focus on life insurance and other similar products, but the lack of information is still a major oversight.

There is information available to contact customer support and a customer access point where policyholders can log into the company’s system to manage accounts. The website does not say whether there is any claims access through this portal.

It seems likely that American National directs claims through the customer support line or accepts them through the agents that sell its products, but without any real information on the website, it’s difficult to say with any certainty.

What are the consumer complaints about American National insurance?

American National Insurance is not BBB accredited, nor is it rated by the BBB. There are, however, 21 complaints listed in the last three years, six of which have been closed in the past 12 months. Those are low numbers for such a large company.

Reviews of American National are mixed, but there are a good number of positive reviews, which is always encouraging. There are more positive reviews for the company’s life insurance subsidiary than for the property & casualty company, but overall there are still enough good reviews to easily balance out the negative ones. Most complaints center on claims issues.

What are the financial strength ratings for American National insurance?

A.M. Best awards American National insurance an A for financial strength. S&P gives them the same rating.

What is the trade information for American National insurance company?

Are you interested in buying stock in American National Insurance? The symbol on the NASDAQ is ANAT and the total value reached $28.5 billion in 2019.

The following companies fall under the parent company of American National:

• Garden State Life Insurance Company
• Standard Life and Accident Insurance Company
• American National Life Insurance Company of New York
• Farm Family Companies
• American National Property and Casualty Company (ANPAC)
• American National Life Insurance Company of Texas

American National insurance company also raises funds for Children of the Ozarks, United Way of the Ozarks, Boys and Girls Clubs, and the Salvation Army.

What are American National insurance company’s recognitions and awards?

In 2003, American National insurance company was recognized for its organizational performance management and customer service excellence and received the Missouri Quality Award. Six years later, they were highlighted as one of the “100 Most Trustworthy Agencies” by Forbes Magazine, then again in 2019 as one of the “Best Mid-sized Employers” by Forbes.

What’s the bottom line?

The lack of information regarding the details of the company’s products makes it difficult to get a clear picture of what it offers and whether it’s a good value for consumers. American National has a fairly good reputation, with more positive reviews than are commonly seen for a property & casualty company.

It may be worth a look for those who prefer to use an agent. American National is a big player in the life insurance market. That said, it’s difficult to provide a real recommendation for this company due to the overall lack of information on products and claims processes. It’s also worth noting that American National Insurance Company has battled class-action lawsuits in the past.

If you’re looking for American National (ANICO) insurance quotes, enter your ZIP code into our FREE quote tool below.

Frequently Asked Questions: American National (ANICO) Insurance Review & Complaints

Hopefully, we’ve answered all your questions, but just in case, take a look at some commonly asked ones below.

#1 — Who owns American National insurance company?

The Moody Foundation and Libbie Shearn Moody Trust run American National Insurance Company, which is owned by the Moody family. The company was founded in Texas.

#2 — Where is American National insurance?

As mentioned above, American National Insurance can be found all over the country. Check out the company’s website to find American National Insurance’s phone number and American National Insurance’s address for your specific state.

#3 — How do I get a job at American National insurance?

American National Insurance careers may be available in your area. If you’re wondering, “How much do American National Insurance agents make?” or, “Does American National Insurance drug test?” — check out the website.